Contents

The Hunger Project Online Briefing Program 
The Condition of Women in South Asia

 

Contents 

 

Introduction to Unit 4: The Condition of Women in 
South Asia

Unit 4 of the Online Briefing Program looks at the conditions of life for rural women in South Asia. It examines the link between the subjugation of women and the persistence of hunger.

In South Asia - like in many developing countries - society holds women responsible for all the key actions required to end hunger: family nutrition, health, education, food production and – increasingly – family income. Yet at the same time – through laws, custom and tradition – women are denied the resources, the information and freedom of action they need to carry out these responsibilities.  This situation holds hunger in place.

In the coming pages, we will travel through the life of a rural South Asian woman, from birth until widowhood. Her life is not an easy one - she is unwanted, disadvantaged, threatened by violence, overworked, and even outcast. In spite of these harsh conditions, she is a critical provider for her family and a key producer for her country.  

This lifetime may not apply to each and every rural woman in India and Bangladesh. Yet it does aim to candidly confront the situation of millions of Indian and Bangladeshi women, who are subjugated, marginalized and disempowered every day of their lives. It reflects the voices of rural South Asian women, as well as urban activists, many of whom have grappled with the extreme differences between their own upbringing, and the life of their rural sisters.

As investors around the world, our challenge is to confront the reality of life for the millions of subjugated women - our partners in ending hunger.  The actions that must be taken to end hunger in India and Bangladesh will be taken by these impoverished, malnourished, illiterate women themselves.  As we immerse ourselves in the coming pages, we can begin to appreciate the courage of the Indian and Bangladeshi women who are working to provide for their families and themselves. 

At the September 23rd launching event, you will have the opportunity to experience these issues even more powerfully as you pass through an exhibition outside the main ballroom. To reserve your seat at the event today, e-mail Marty Corley at mlc@thp.org.  

 

Outline of Unit 4 


A lifetime of subjugation for women: the link to the persistence of hunger in South Asia
  1. Unwanted before birth 

  2. Disadvantaged as a baby girl  

  3. Childhood of drudgery, 
    denied education:
    education and the persistence of hunger

  4. Married and secluded as a girl

  5. In poor health and uncared for in pregnancy

  6. The cycle of malnutrition

  7. Overworked and invisible producer

  8. Outcast in widowhood

  9. Threatened by violence throughout her life: violence and the persistence of hunger

  10. Awakening to a new possibility

1. Unwanted From Birth

A baby girl in South Asia is unwanted before she is even born. The inequality between women and men is one of the most critical factors in the persistence of hunger.

Oh, God, I beg of you,
I touch your feet time and again,
Next birth don't give me a daughter,
Give me Hell instead...
-Folk Song from Uttar Pradesh, India

A person has to have sinned in his past life to be born a woman.
–Ancient Indian Proverb

Pray for a boy  

 

 

The tradition of dowry 

Missing Women

South Asia is the only region in the world where there are more men than women - where the natural ratio of women to men is severely distorted.  This is due to the profound inequalities between women and men.

It's cruel. If you have a daughter, you are pitied and your social status is dismal. Better to have a son than to listen to all the taunts.
-Paramjit Kaur, anganwadi (nursery) worker

Missing women

Not allowed to live

A deeply embedded issue

2. Disadvantaged as an Infant

A young girl in South Asia is never considered a real member of the family. She is fed poorer quality food than her brothers, and is denied health care when she is ill. This mistreatment is closely linked to higher rates of girl's malnutrition and the persistence of hunger.

Young girls are thought of, and often called, 'guests.' The meaning is clear: she will eventually leave her paternal home. Implicit is the thought that too much trouble will not be taken in her upbringing.
-Author and researcher Dr. Martha Chen speaking of Bangladeshi women

Unequal treatment

 

Cost to society


 

3. Childhood of Drudgery 

The reality of a girl child's existence is drudgery, both inside and outside the home.  

Childhood of work

Education and social opinion

Even though they [girls] are clever they have no chance to go to school. They are forced to go to work at an early age, and there is also child marriage.
-Indian man 

Social Benefits of Education

When girls are educated, there are enormous social benefits.  The lack of education holds hunger in place.

Educating a man is educating an individual, while educating a woman is educating a family.

-Mahatma Gandhi

Social benefits

4. Adolescence - the Walls Close in: Married as Girl

Girls in South Asia are married very young - often as children.  They have children at an early age. This is harmful to their health and limits their participation in activities that bring about the end of hunger.

With the addition of a girl to the household, the in-laws get a laborer, someone who will feed the cattle and clear the house, a servant who comes free of cost.
-Ratan Katyani, social worker in Jaipur, India

When a family's eldest daughter is married, her younger sisters may also be married off at the same time to save expense.     (Photo by Sondeep Shankar)

Married as a child

Of course, we know that marrying children is against the law, but it's only a paper law.
- Govind Singh Patel, village elder in Rajasthan

Pregnant before she is ready

Secluded as a Young Wife

As wives, women are confined to the home and expected to serve their husbands. 

A good woman regards her husband as her god…A good woman leaves her husband’s home only for the cremation grounds. –traditional Indian saying

Secluded and confined

To go out by the front door or back door of the house is forbidden for me. I can't go to my family's house. Everyone else here is used to it. But to me it is intolerable because I was not brought up in this environment. Therefore, sometimes the house seems to me like a jail.
-Young woman from Bogra, Bangladesh 

5. In Poor Health in Womanhood

Women suffer from poor health and lack of health care - even when they are pregnant.

In poor health

Denied care in pregnancy

Maternal mortality


6. The Cycle of Malnutrition

Ill-health and malnutrition of women is critically linked to the persistence of hunger. When women are malnourished, their children are malnourished.

The exceptionally high rates of malnutrition in South Asia are rooted deep in the soil of inequality between men and women. 
–UNICEF 1996, The Asian Enigma

East last, eat least

From mother to child

Cost of Malnutrition

The malnutrition of women - from the womb, to their own pregnancy - has dire consequences for the family and society.

The cost

8. Overworked and Unacknowledged

South Asian women are critical producers for their families, communities, and countries. In spite of their contributions, their work goes unpaid and unacknowledged.

My field is in the hills, it takes so much weeding. For how many years will we die from toil?

…to fetch, to carry, to cook, to wash…year after year a submissive silent slave sold to life for nothing.

-
Indian women

Dual responsibilities

 

Unacknowledged work

Productive Contributions

South Asian women are critical producers for their families, communities, and countries.  Without their contributions, South Asia's productivity would be lost.

Critical producers

    In Bangladesh, women: 

 

Rural production, industry and manufacturing

Household work

 

9. Outcast in Widowhood


As widows, women suffer some of the most severe subjugation of their whole lives. Widowed women are harassed, abused, and denied land and livelihood.

'Keep your eyes downcast. You are a widow, now.' My mother-in-law ordered me. 'You have eaten up my son, so you must suffer.'

Widow from Bihar, India

When my husband died, my neighbors wanted my land. When I go to the bazaar, they steal what few crops I have.

-Bangladeshi woman

Subjugation of widows


 

No land or security

Threatened by Violence 

Hunger persists because women are deprived of equal status in society. This system of inequality is kept in place by violence and the threat of violence. 

Violence is designed to keep women suppressed in the family and society. It starts from childhood and is part of the way parents bring up their daughters, for instance, always telling them 'Don't speak loudly.' According to the prevailing social customs, if a woman is the victim of violence, she is blamed rather than sympathized with.

-Bangladeshi man

You should not beat your wife, but if the food is not ready, if the rotis are not hot, what choice do you have?

-Male, Jat, Uttar Pradesh

The system of violence holds hunger in place

Violence in the Life-Cycle

Violence against women persists at all stages of women's lives. It is part of the same system the holds hunger in place.

Women have been taught to believe that suffering and maltreatment are 'normal' and 'a woman's fate'  The religion, films, her elders and her mother's experiences consistently tell her that if she is unhappy, nothing can be done, and that it is her own fault.

-Study on bride burning in India

The system of violence holds hunger in place

Dowry deaths

Life-cycle

The Hunger Project Online Briefing Program 
The Condition of Women in South Asia
Page 21 of 25

   At a Glance

 

Awakening

In the 1980s, a new sense of possibility for India's women began to surface across the country.  Although obstacles persist, India's women are showing themselves to be up for the challenge.

A new possibility

Promise of local government

 Obstacles persist

The Condition of Women in South Asia - At a Glance

Congratulations on finishing unit 4 of the online briefing program. This unit has looked at the life of a South Asian woman, and the link between women's subjugation and the persistence of hunger in South Asia.

Life of a South Asian Woman